Horror Fuel

Directors P.J. Starks and Eric Huckisson are Back with “New Fears Eve: Part Two”

Kelli Marchman McNeely November 9, 2026
3–4 minutes
Holiday Slasher 'New Fears Eve' Turns Troll Comments into a Hilarious New Trailer
Advertisement

The creative team behind New Fears Eve is officially preparing an exciting sequel. Co-directors P.J. Starks and Eric Huskisson return to helm the next installment, and we are so here for it. Horror icon Jeffrey Reddick also returns to produce New Fears Eve: Part 2.

A Fast-Tracked Screenplay

The original film left audiences clinging to a tense cliffhanger. However, the writer intentionally planned that ending to set up this exciting follow-up. After the film was released, the filmmakers didn’t waste any time moving forward. Starks actually completed the sequel’s entire screenplay in just two weeks.

Ramped-Up Gore and Humor

The narrative strikes a careful balance between dramatic tension and outrageous comedy. Starks also promises hilarious, over-the-top set pieces that expand on the original. The story combines meta horror mystery with raunchy ensemble humor. Therefore, fans can expect a massive second act packed with practical effects.

Advertisement

Although the sequel reportedly features fewer overall deaths, the team aims to push the visceral intensity much further. They aim to make every kill unique, brutal, and memorable. As a result, gorehounds will experience extraordinary bloody carnage.

The Co-directors, Starks and Huskisson, told us the following about the good news.

Starks said, “Fans of the original film will be in for a ride with the sequel. The first act goes from zero to sixty and doesn’t let off the gas. It’s a lot more of what everyone loved about the first film with more unique and insane kills, dark subversive comedy, as well as unexpected surprises. However, it’s also very different focusing on our core group and how the New Year’s massacre at Hooper Inc. has affected their lives and relationships. It’s Scream 2 meets American Pie 2. We’re putting a pitch deck together now for investors. This one is bigger and better in every way and we’re excited to hopefully bring it to life.
Huskisson added “New Fears Eve Part 2 will leave your mouth watering for New Fears Eve Part 3! New gore, new twists and turns, new characters, new victims, same gruesome Doctor. If you liked NFE then you’ll love NFE2.

Returning Stars and New Talent

The directors plan to bring back as much of the original crew as possible. After all, the first project built a tight, collaborative team environment. Key cast members will also reprise their popular roles.

Lily-Claire Harvey, whom I interviewed about the original film, returns as Leslie to face the deadly killer once more. Likewise, Jesse McDonald returns to play both Ned and the murderous killer, “The Doctor.” Meanwhile, the team is actively casting new roles for this ambitious follow-up. Specifically, they plan to fill fresh roles with recognizable genre stars. Pre-production is underway so that horror fans can expect another blood-soaked ride.

Revisiting the Original Bloodbath

The original story follows three reluctant co-workers as they host their company’s annual New Year’s Eve celebration. However, the festive gathering quickly turns into a desperate fight for survival. An unexpected guest suddenly crashes the party.

Specifically, an unhinged, masked serial killer known as “The Doctor” invades the event. Armed with surgical precision, the killer systematically dismantles the entire guest list. Directing duo Starks and Huskisson crafted the feature as a love letter to 1980s slasher classics.

The film balances workplace humor with over forty elaborate practical kills. Special effects artist Stephen J. Hodke handled the in-camera gore alongside Isa Suzanne and Blaze Bolden. Keep an eye out for more updates on New Fears Eve: Part 2. 

YouTube sets cookies once the video loads

Fans can stream the first movie now on Prime Video and Tubi, but a physical Blu-ray belongs in your collection. You can get it now. If you want more killer horror from the team, I recommend the Christmas horror anthology 13 Slays Till-Xmas, also available on Tubi.

Share
Kelli Marchman McNeely

Kelli Marchman McNeely

Kelli Marchman McNeely is the owner and editor of HorrorFuel.com. She has long had a love for the horror genre since she saw her first horror movie, Friday the 13th at the age of nine. She also serves as an executive producer for films like 13 Slays till X-Mas.

All articles by this author →
AdvertisementParamount+

More from the Crypt